The example listing
We'll work through one listing: a three-bedroom, 1.5-bath, 1,350 sq ft house listed at $185,000. The tax history shows $3,600 a year, there's no HOA, and similar houses nearby rent for about $1,750 a month.
Minute 1: Screen the basics
Before any math, read the listing like an investor:
- Price per square foot against recent sales nearby. A big gap either way needs a reason.
- Year built and condition. Older houses and listings with words like "as-is," "investor special" or "needs TLC" mean a bigger repair budget.
- Days on market and price history. A listing that has sat for 60+ days or already had price cuts gives you room to negotiate.
- The 1% rule as a quick screen. Rent ÷ price: $1,750 ÷ $185,000 = 0.95%. Close enough to keep going. Well under 0.7% in most markets, and a rental rarely works.
Minute 2: Get the real costs
- Property taxes: use the tax history on the listing, not the payment estimate. Check whether your county reassesses after a sale; if it does, your bill may go up.
- HOA dues: listed on the page when there are any. Read them carefully on condos and townhouses, and check whether the HOA allows rentals at all.
- Insurance: get a landlord policy quote. A rough figure is fine for screening.
- Flood risk: a flood zone can add a large insurance bill. Many listings show a flood or climate risk section; check it.
Ignore Zillow's monthly payment estimate. It's built for someone moving in, typically with owner-occupant loan terms, and it leaves out vacancy, repairs and management.
Minute 3: Find the real rent
Zillow's Rent Zestimate, where it's shown, is a starting point. Confirm it by searching rentals nearby with the same bed and bath count, and give more weight to ones that actually leased recently than to ones still sitting on the market. When the estimate and the comps disagree, use the lower number.
Minute 4: Run the rental numbers
Net operating income and cap rate
| Gross rent ($1,750 × 12) | $21,000 |
| Vacancy (5%) | − $1,050 |
| Effective gross income | $19,950 |
| Property taxes | − $3,600 |
| Insurance | − $1,350 |
| Repairs (5% of rent) | − $1,050 |
| Capital reserve (5% of rent) | − $1,050 |
| Management (8% of rent) | − $1,680 |
| Net operating income | $11,220 |
For how each line works and what a good cap rate is, see how to calculate cap rate.
Cash flow with an investor loan
Now add financing: 25% down, a 30-year loan at 7.25%, and about 3% in closing costs. The loan is $138,750 and the payment is $946.52 a month.
| Net operating income | $11,220 |
| Mortgage payments ($946.52 × 12) | − $11,358 |
| Yearly cash flow | − $138 |
| Cash invested (down payment + closing) | $51,800 |
| Cash-on-cash return | −0.3% |
| DSCR (NOI ÷ mortgage payments) | 0.99 |
At the asking price, this house loses a little money every year, and a DSCR of 0.99 means the rent doesn't quite cover the loan. That's what happens when the cap rate (6.06%) is below the loan's interest rate (7.25%): the borrowed money costs more than the property earns on it.
Work back to a price that works
Keeping the same rent and costs, and assuming the taxes stay the same, two quick ways to set your offer:
- Target cap rate: for a 7% cap rate, $11,220 ÷ 0.07 = $160,286.
- Target cash flow: at about $153,000, the same loan terms leave roughly $150 a month in cash flow, with a DSCR of 1.19.
So this is a rental at roughly $153,000–$160,000, not at $185,000. That's a $25,000–$32,000 gap. Whether it's worth an offer depends on how long it has been listed and how motivated the seller is.
Minute 5: Check the flip and wholesale angle
A house that fails as a rental might still work as a flip. Filter Zillow for recently sold homes nearby, find renovated ones similar in size, and estimate the after-repair value (ARV). Say renovated comps support an ARV of $245,000 and the house needs $35,000 of work:
A wholesaler with a $10,000 fee would need to contract at $126,500 or less. Both are far below the $185,000 asking price, so this listing isn't a flip or a wholesale deal at its current price. The wholesale MAO guide explains the percentages and what to do when the seller wants more.
The verdict on this listing
Five minutes in, here's what we know:
- As a rental: doesn't work at $185,000. Works at about $153,000–$160,000.
- As a flip: max offer about $136,500.
- Next step: if it has been sitting or had price cuts, an offer in the mid-$150,000s as a rental is worth a try. If not, move on to the next listing.
That's the point of a five-minute routine: most listings don't work, and you want to find that out fast so you can spend your time on the ones that might.
Common mistakes when analyzing Zillow listings
- Using the Zestimate as ARV or value. It doesn't know the condition inside.
- Trusting the monthly payment estimate instead of investor loan terms.
- Skipping vacancy, capital reserves and management, which can make a negative deal look positive.
- Taking the listing's rent claim at face value. Check it against real rentals.
- Falling for the house. If the numbers only work at a price the seller won't take, it isn't your deal.
To run your own listing, the free rental cash flow calculator gives you cash flow, cap rate, cash-on-cash and DSCR from the price, rent and loan, and the 70% rule calculator handles the flip check.