The formula
All-in cost is everything you spend until the property is rented: purchase price, closing costs, rehab, holding costs during the rehab, and loan costs if you used a short-term loan. Refi loan is the appraised value (your after-repair value) times the lender's maximum loan-to-value.
Example: a cash purchase
You buy a house for $95,000 in cash, spend $30,000 on a four-month rehab, rent it for $1,450 a month, and it appraises at $150,000. The lender will refinance at 75% of value.
What you put in
| Purchase price | $95,000 |
| Closing costs to buy (3%) | $2,850 |
| Rehab | $30,000 |
| Taxes, insurance and utilities during rehab | $2,400 |
| All-in cost | $130,250 |
What the refinance gives back
| Appraised value | $150,000 |
| Refi loan (75%) | $112,500 |
| Refi closing costs (~3% of the loan) | − $3,375 |
| Cash back to you | $109,125 |
You started with $130,250 of your own money and got $109,125 back. $21,125 stays in the property, along with $37,500 of equity (the $150,000 value minus the $112,500 loan).
What the rental earns after the refi
The refinance gives you a new 30-year mortgage on $112,500. At 7.5%, the payment is $786.62 a month. Here's the rental with taxes of $2,400 and insurance of $1,200 a year, and the usual reserves:
| Gross rent ($1,450 × 12) | $17,400 |
| Vacancy (5%) | − $870 |
| Taxes and insurance | − $3,600 |
| Repairs, capital reserve and management (18% of rent) | − $3,132 |
| Net operating income | $9,798 |
| Mortgage payments ($786.62 × 12) | − $9,439 |
| Yearly cash flow | $359 ($30 a month) |
| Cash-on-cash return ($359 ÷ $21,125) | 1.7% |
| DSCR (NOI ÷ mortgage payments) | 1.04 |
This deal "works" in the sense that most of your money came back, but it barely cash flows: $30 a month is one repair away from negative, and a DSCR of 1.04 is below what many DSCR lenders want to see (often 1.1–1.25). That's common at today's refinance rates, and it's why you run the post-refi numbers before you buy, not after.
The two levers: purchase price and rent
Change one input at a time, keeping everything else the same:
| Scenario | Cash left | Cash flow | Cash-on-cash | DSCR |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buy at $95,000, rent $1,450 | $21,125 | $30/mo | 1.7% | 1.04 |
| Buy at $85,000, rent $1,450 | $10,825 | $30/mo | 3.3% | 1.04 |
| Buy at $95,000, rent $1,600 | $21,125 | $145/mo | 8.3% | 1.18 |
| Buy at $85,000, rent $1,600 | $10,825 | $145/mo | 16.1% | 1.18 |
The pattern: purchase price decides how much cash comes back, because the refi loan depends on the appraised value, not on what you paid. Rent decides cash flow, because the mortgage is the same either way. A good BRRRR needs both: a discount on the buy and rent that covers the new loan with room to spare.
Getting all your money out
To pull every dollar back out of the $130,250 version, the refinance would need to net $130,250. At 75% loan-to-value and 3% refi costs, that takes an appraisal of about $179,000. Either the house has to be worth more after the rehab, or you have to buy and fix it for less.
Example: the same deal with hard money
Now finance the purchase and rehab with a hard-money loan: 90% of the price plus 100% of the rehab ($115,500), at 11% interest and 2 points, for the four-month rehab.
| All-in cost from the cash example | $130,250 |
| Loan points (2%) | + $2,310 |
| Interest (11%, 4 months) | + $4,235 |
| All-in cost with hard money | $136,795 |
| Cash back from the refinance | − $109,125 |
| Cash left in deal | $27,670 |
The refinance has to pay off the $115,500 hard-money loan first, and its $109,125 isn't quite enough, so you bring $6,375 to the refi closing on top of the down payment and costs you already paid. Hard money lets you start with much less cash (about $21,300 up front here instead of $130,250), but it leaves about $6,500 more in the deal. That's the trade.
Common BRRRR mistakes
- Assuming the appraisal. Your ARV is an estimate; the lender's appraiser decides. Use conservative sold comps.
- Not asking about seasoning and loan-to-value first. A 12-month wait or a 70% limit changes the whole plan.
- Forgetting refi closing costs and the hard-money payoff. Both come out of what you get back.
- Ignoring post-refi cash flow. Getting your money out of a property that loses money every month isn't a win.
- Over-improving. Rehab that doesn't raise the appraisal or the rent only adds to cash left in the deal.
Run your own deal in the free BRRRR calculator, which handles both cash and hard-money purchases. For the rental side on its own, see how to calculate cap rate and how to analyze a Zillow listing in 5 minutes.