The two formulas
Net operating income (NOI) is rent after vacancy minus operating expenses, before the mortgage. Cash flow is NOI minus the mortgage payments. Cash invested is your down payment, closing costs and any upfront repairs.
Cap rate is the same for every buyer of a property. Cash-on-cash changes with each buyer's loan. That's the whole difference, and it's why you use them for different jobs.
Same house, two buyers
A rental listed at $200,000 produces $13,000 of NOI a year. Its cap rate is $13,000 ÷ $200,000 = 6.5%, no matter who buys it. Closing costs are 3% ($6,000).
Buyer 1 pays cash
| Cash invested ($200,000 + $6,000 closing) | $206,000 |
| Yearly cash flow (all of the NOI) | $13,000 |
| Cash-on-cash return | 6.31% |
With no loan, cash-on-cash is just under the cap rate, because closing costs add to the cash invested.
Buyer 2 puts 25% down at 7%
| Cash invested ($50,000 down + $6,000 closing) | $56,000 |
| Net operating income | $13,000 |
| Mortgage payments ($150,000, 30 years, 7%) | − $11,975 |
| Yearly cash flow | $1,025 |
| Cash-on-cash return | 1.83% |
Same house, same 6.5% cap rate, but the buyer with a loan earns 1.83% on their cash. Borrowing made the return worse, not better. The next section explains why.
When borrowing helps: the loan-constant test
Compare the cap rate with the loan constant: the yearly mortgage payment divided by the loan amount.
A 30-year loan at 7% costs $11,975 a year on $150,000, a loan constant of 7.98%. It's higher than the 7% interest rate because each payment also repays principal.
- Cap rate above the loan constant: each borrowed dollar earns more than it costs, so a loan raises your cash-on-cash return. This is positive leverage.
- Cap rate below the loan constant: each borrowed dollar costs more than it earns, so a loan lowers your cash-on-cash return. This is negative leverage, and it's what happened to Buyer 2: 6.5% against 7.98%.
A property where the loan helps
Now a cheaper rental: $120,000 with $10,800 of NOI, a 9% cap rate, above the 7.98% loan constant.
| Cash invested | Cash flow | Cash-on-cash | |
|---|---|---|---|
| All cash | $123,600 | $10,800 | 8.74% |
| 25% down at 7% | $33,600 | $3,615 | 10.76% |
Here the loan lifts cash-on-cash from 8.74% to 10.76%, and the DSCR is a comfortable 1.50. Same loan terms as before; the difference is entirely the property's cap rate.
Which one to use, and when
| Question | Use |
|---|---|
| Is this property priced well compared with others? | Cap rate |
| What should I offer? | Cap rate (NOI ÷ target cap rate) |
| What will my own money earn this year? | Cash-on-cash return |
| Should I use a loan, and how much? | Both: cap rate vs. loan constant |
| Will a DSCR lender approve it? | DSCR (NOI ÷ mortgage payments) |
What cash-on-cash leaves out
Cash-on-cash counts only spendable cash. Buyer 2's mortgage also pays down about $1,524 of principal in year one. Counting that, their total first-year return is about 4.55%, better than 1.83% but still below the all-cash buyer's 6.31%. Appreciation and tax benefits add more on top, but none of it pays the bills until you sell or refinance. That's why cash flow comes first for most rental investors.
Common mistakes
- Comparing one property's cap rate with another's cash-on-cash. They measure different things.
- Assuming a loan always boosts returns. It only does when the cap rate beats the loan constant.
- Leaving closing costs and upfront repairs out of cash invested, which overstates cash-on-cash.
- Using a thin NOI. Both metrics fall apart if vacancy, capital reserves or management are missing. See how to calculate cap rate for a complete NOI.
Run your own numbers in the free cash-on-cash return calculator and the cap rate calculator, or see both on a real listing in how to analyze a Zillow listing in 5 minutes.